Artisan jewelry, gift and whiskey shops crowd the main street of Kirkwall on the Orkney Islands. The town even boasts a recently opened sushi shop, serving bento boxes and green tea dessert.
Historically inhabited by the Viking earls who governed the islands, Kirkwall has hit it rich: it ranks first in the UK’s charts for cruise ship arrivals, as US, European and Italian tourists descend on extraordinary neolithic sites such as Skara Brae and its medieval cathedral.
But numerous Orcadians are frustrated: welcoming about 450,000 tourists a year, twentyfold the resident count of twenty-two thousand, has a significant cost. Its small streets are congested, local transport overloaded, the ancient monuments at Brodgar are now barricaded to repair the erosion by visitors. Some tourists, struggling to locate restrooms, have even been accused of defecating in the open.
Struggling to Cover the Costs of Visitor Facilities
Finding it hard to fund the costs of building new restrooms, coach parks and paths to adequately accommodate visitors, the council and its industry representatives want the power to introduce a novel fee for every tourist who arrives on the islands, by either sea or air.
Orkney islands council has teamed up with Shetland and Comhairle nan Eilean Siar to press the Scottish government to authorize a point of entry levy included in tickets set by ship companies, ferry companies and the local carrier Loganair.
Martin Fleet, chief executive of the family-owned jewelry business a renowned brand, and chair of the business group the tourism board, projects that a standard five pound fee for every visitor could collect around £2m a year, once administration costs are deducted.
“Orkney, neighboring isles, Western Isles, which have small population numbers, have remarkable sites which people want to come and see, but we must make sure that we preserve those assets for posterity who reside locally and also those that want to visit,” he said.
“We don’t want people to cease coming here. We just need to be extremely careful about how tourism is handled.”
Government Considering Tourist Levy Options
The national administration has stated it is considering a point of entry levy as part of a broader consultation on introducing a levy specifically for passenger vessels, which local governments with popular cruise ports could use for new tourism infrastructure and local services.
Local officials strongly contend that tourist levies are essential to augment a £647m shortfall in government funding and to assist in managing the millions of tourists Scotland welcomes each year. Outcomes of the review are scheduled for release in the near future.
The nation currently possesses the UK’s first legislation to permit councils to introduce a “overnight levy” – a visitor levy on accommodations, bed and breakfasts and camping grounds. Edinburgh’s is now active, with tourists now paying a 5% additional fee on all rooms reserved from 24 July 2026 forward, capped at five nights.
Aberdeen and Glasgow are following suit, but additional local authorities across the northern regions have declined that approach, often after a backlash from enterprises, arguing a charge on accommodations is excessively onerous and is also off-putting for guests.
Alternative Solutions for Island Communities
The Shetland Islands has turned down a tourist fee; Orkney and the Western Isles have “paused” it, hoping a more suitable alternative such as a point of entry levy arrives.
An industry body, an trade association, has objected that a cruise ship levy will deter many of the over a million passengers who visit each year, “causing serious consequences for the nation's maritime tourism, its vulnerable coastal economies, and the country’s reputation as a internationally attractive tourism destination”.
Local authorities contends a arrival levy treats all tourists equally. It covers the two hundred fourteen thousand passenger liner visitors who landed there in last year and the 173,000 who arrived by ferry and air, encompassing motor home drivers, campers and lodging patrons, and those on personal boats.
The local government and the heritage agency, the agency which protects Orkney’s ancient UNESCO site, are immersed in an exhaustive initiative to build a recently planned visitors centre, bus parking, access paths and toilets to accommodate crowds at the ancient stone circle and Skara Brae.
Partly funded by the islands growth deal set up by the UK and Scottish governments, that could take up to eight years to realise: constructing on a protected heritage site is a careful process.
Community and Industry Perspectives
Christie Hartley, the authority's sustainable tourism lead, said the Scottish government required to set out its thinking promptly, to avoid the cruise sector “getting riled up”, but she said a levy would benefit everyone involved.
“Generally speaking, there is little relationship typically between ship operators and the communities that they promote – they market two things: the journey of their ships and the destinations,” she remarked.
Although they have a very strong relationship with coach companies and port officials, “how about the local populations that we have a responsibility to safeguard and support? This is a massive chance for us to truly develop those relationships to shared advantage.
“By funding in infrastructure, they can enhance the experience for their guests, they can increase prices, they can have the security of knowing what they’re going to get. It's well known we have issues with the shortage of restrooms and aspects in our delicate community that are difficult to handle with the number of people.”
Kristopher Leask, a councillor and chair of the islands' development and infrastructure committee, said tourists are more and more eco-conscious and conscientious. “There is an opportunity available: to have a good framework in place, to have a positive partnership and for the charge to actually prove highly beneficial,” he said.